Home › How We Rate

How we rate

The Bucket Rating, explained.

Every pick on this site gets one of four ratings. The rating answers one question: how far out of your way should you go for this?

The four ratings

These are the only four ratings we use, from the top down. They are the same four used in the Kick the Bucket List books.

Plan the trip around it. These are the places the rest of the itinerary should bend to fit: the landmark, the meal, or the drive that defines the state.

Worth going out of your way for, even if it means a dedicated drive. Not quite the reason to visit the state, but a strong reason to visit the region.

Good fun, real character, not a priority. Roadside oddities, small festivals, and touristy-but-honest stops tend to land here. Do it when the schedule has room.

Worth a stop if you're nearby. Don't build a trip around it. A place also lands here when it can't currently deliver what made it famous, for example when it has closed to the public.

What about "skip"?

"Skip" is not a rating. A place that isn't worth the trip at all doesn't make the list. Instead, skips show up inside the pages: most pick pages have a section on what to skip, like the overpriced add-on, the crowded weekend, or the tourist version down the road.

The verdict line

Each rating comes with a one-line verdict that says why. The rating is the short answer; the verdict is the reason. The verdict is our opinion and we own it. The facts inside it (years, prices, hours, distances) have to be checkable.

The Kick-It seal

The boot kicking the bucket is on our books and our logo. In the books, the seal marks the entries singled out as Kick-It Picks, and those are the entries that get their own page on this site. The seal is not a fifth rating. Read the Bucket Rating for the verdict.

How the Verified date works

Every pick page and article ends with a stamp like "Verified 2026-07." That is the year and month we last checked the page's facts against a primary source, such as the operator's own website, the National Park Service, a state park system, or the agency that runs the road.

• Check the date before a long drive. Prices and hours change between checks.
• Expect the date to move when we re-check a page and update it.
• Confirm hours, fees, and access directly with the place before you go.

Ratings change when the facts change

A rating is only as good as the last time we checked. When hours, access, or the place itself changes, the rating can change too, and it can go down.

One real example: Highlands Bar & Grill in Birmingham won the James Beard Outstanding Restaurant award in 2018. In July 2026 the page rated it Non-negotiable. When we re-checked in October 2026, the restaurant was still closed to the public, as it has been since 2020, with no reopening date. We moved it to Only if you're already close, rewrote the page to point readers to its sibling restaurants, and updated the stamp to Verified 2026-10.

Spot something that has changed? Tell us and we will re-check it.

Books never buy a better rating

We write and sell the Kick the Bucket List books, and some links on this site are affiliate links. None of that touches a rating. Here is how we keep editorial and commerce apart:

• No place pays to be listed, and no place can pay for a better rating.
• A rating never goes up to sell a book or earn a commission.
• The site does not wait for a new book edition to downgrade a place. When the facts change, the page changes.

Read the full affiliate disclosure for how the site makes money.