Illustrated featured image of South Carolina Barbecue, statewide, South Carolina — a Kick-It Pick
Eats · Midlands South Carolina

South Carolina Barbecue Review

Pick Your Sauce and Your Side of the State · statewide
A Kick-It Pick
Non-negotiable
the only state with all four barbecue sauces, led by a mustard-gold sauce found nowhere else. Eat across the sauce map; stand in the woodsmoke at a real whole-hog pit.

South Carolina is the only state that claims all four of the major barbecue sauces, and which one lands on your pulled pork is a matter of pure geography. The state’s signature — found almost nowhere else on Earth — is the tangy golden mustard sauce of the German “Dutch Fork” belt around Columbia and Lexington. To the east in the Pee Dee it’s a thin, fiery vinegar-and-pepper mop; in the Upstate it’s a light tomato sauce; toward the coast, a heavier sweet tomato. Under all of it is the whole-hog tradition of the Black pitmasters who created it. Eating your way across the sauce map — mustard here, vinegar there — is one of the great edible road trips in the South.

The move: Try the mustard sauce first (Shealy's, or any Midlands pit) because it's the one you can't get anywhere else, then chase the vinegar-pepper whole-hog in the Pee Dee (Scott's in Hemingway). Get hash over rice wherever you see it. Don't take a side in the sauce war unless you enjoy an argument. Buy bottles to bring the map home.
Cost~$12–20 a plate
Time neededa meal (or a road trip)
Best seasonyear-round
Wherestatewide · Midlands Alabama

Common questions

When's the best time to visit South Carolina Barbecue?

Best season: year-round.

How much does it cost?

~$12–20 a plate. Prices drift — confirm before you go.

How long should I plan for?

Plan for about a meal (or a road trip).

Is it actually worth the trip?

Our rating: Non-negotiable. The only state with all four barbecue sauces, led by a mustard-gold sauce found nowhere else. Eat across the sauce map; stand in the woodsmoke at a real whole-hog pit.

Kicked it? Send us your photo and the date you went to kicked@kickitpicks.com — the best ones get featured on this page.

One of 120 in Kick the Bucket List: South Carolina

The full book is 120 checkable picks like this one — with a Bucket Rating on every entry telling you what's worth the drive and what to skip. A keepsake you fill in and score.

Get the South Carolina book →

More South Carolina Kick-It Picks

Verified 2026-07. Prices and hours change — confirm before you drive. Something wrong? Tell us.